Tensions are high at Anfield after Liverpool’s humiliating defeat to Eintracht Frankfurt, and the storm clouds haven’t cleared. Former Reds defender and Sky Sports pundit Jamie Carragher has now joined the growing list of voices demanding accountability — calling for Arne Slot to immediately drop a key player who he believes has become a “liability at both ends of the pitch.”
Speaking live after the match, Carragher didn’t hold back his emotions.
“After that embarrassing display against Frankfurt, there’s absolutely no reason he should start today vs Brentford,” he said sharply.
“If Arne Slot still plays him, then I’m sorry — he has no idea what he’s doing. Either he’s too soft to drop him or scared of the backlash. A real coach benches a liability, not pampers him. Take it or leave it — he’s a disaster for Liverpool at both ends of the pitch.”
Carragher was reportedly referring to the duo of Alexander Isak and Mohamed Salah, who both failed to make an impact in Liverpool’s 5-1 defeat, raising major questions about Slot’s faith in his forward line.
Fans React — “He Shouldn’t Even Be On The Bench!”
Liverpool fans online have echoed Carragher’s frustration, flooding social media with fierce criticism.
Many are now questioning whether Arne Slot’s loyalty to his attacking stars has blinded him to the harsh reality of their performances.
One fan wrote:
“Carragher is absolutely right. We can’t keep defending poor displays — Isak should be nowhere near that lineup.”
Another added:
“Salah’s body language is off. He doesn’t look hungry anymore. If Slot can’t bench him, then he’s not ready for this job.”
The pressure is now fully on Slot, who faces the daunting task of restoring both balance and belief in a Liverpool squad that looks shaken.
Arne Slot’s Dilemma — Rotation or Rebellion?
Reports from inside the club suggest Slot is torn between sticking with his experienced names or giving fresh faces a chance to prove themselves.
However, many believe that another poor result could push Liverpool deeper into crisis territory, as the Reds risk falling further behind in their pursuit of Premier League glory.
With Brentford next up at Anfield, every lineup decision will be scrutinized, and Carragher’s words have only added more fuel to the fire.
The big question remains:
Will Slot listen to his critics — or will he gamble once again on loyalty over logic?
Fan Sentiment Boiling Over
As one supporter put it bluntly on X:
“Carragher said what every fan is thinking — no more excuses. Drop the dead weight or prepare for another humiliation.”
Liverpool’s identity under Slot was meant to be built on intensity and precision — but right now, fans are only seeing inconsistency and confusion.
If the Dutchman doesn’t act fast, even his most loyal supporters may begin to turn
